Rachel, my boss won’t give me guidance
The writer, a junior planner, says her supervisor changes her work
September 7, 2012
How can I get my boss to give me constructive feedback? I'm a junior planner with limited experience, and I'm very much in need of guidance. While I like my boss — she's a very nice person — I am not getting a good sense from her of what I need to do to improve. She handles changes to my work herself instead of bringing me in on it. I asked her about this once and she said she's happy with my work, but not two days later she was changing it again. How can I get better if I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong? — Sign me Media Maven Jr.
Welcome to the real world.
There is this great notion out there about the ideal mentor-boss who trains and inspires young people in the formative years of their careers.
For sure, there are such mentors out there, but they are fewer than TV and the movies would have us believe.
Many managers find it easier to fix things themselves rather than spend the time to walk their young charges through every change they make. As much as anything, it's about time. As it is, they are already pressed for time, under pressure to meet a slew of deadlines, and getting the work out the door will always come first.
I would take some comfort in your boss's statement that she is happy with your work.
But I would also be prepared to accept the fact that she's not going to give you any more time than she is already.
It's up to you to make up the difference, so to speak—to assume responsibility for your own on-the-job training.
First, I would watch very closely what changes she does make in your work. You are bound to see a pattern in those changes, and you need to take instruction from those changes.
Make a list of the most common changes and use it as a check list to go over before you turn something in.
Then follow up. See whether that reduces the number of changes going forward.
I would also accept the fact that no matter what you do she—any boss, really—is going to make some changes.
But I would also reach out beyond your boss to others you work with for mentoring. There's always one person or a few people in any agency who delight in bringing young people along.
They may not come to you. You have to find them and win them over to your cause.
In the end, you are the one who is most responsible for your professional growth. The sooner you accept that responsibility, the faster you will grow in your career, and the more fun you will have.
CW’s DC Comics crossover finishes strong
Imagining local advertising, 10 years down the road
So cool: Petting cheetahs at the Canberra airport
And now, iHeartRadio hops into on-demand music
Rachel, all they do here is fight and fight
Introducing Media Life’s Out of Home Premium
Weekend TV: College Football Playoffs take shape
Starting Sunday, a new place to watch the NFL
Liga MX playoffs score on Spanish-language TV
The best sports cities: Rankings for big and small
‘Circle of Love’ lifts NBC to best Wednesday in years
This week’s broadcast ratings
Programming blog: What’s canceled and renewed
- Myra Nussbaum becomes group creative director at DDB Chicago
- Claudio de Souza rises to vice president at Isobar U.S.
- Agathe Guerrier becomes head of strategy at BBH Los Angeles
- Stephanie Lee-Pang becomes executive director at Grey New York
- Masami Yamamoto and Lee Straus rise at NBC
- Scot Gillespie becomes VP and CTO at The Washington Post
- Lauren Johnson becomes integrated ad director at Esquire
- Tim Taliaferro becomes editor in chief at Texas Monthly
- Matthew Breen becomes editorial director at Logo
- Chase Green, Lynneise Joseph and Katrina Pallant rise at Africa Channel
- Joe Biden guesting on CBS's 'The Late Show'
This week’s broadcast ratings
This week’s cable ratings
This week’s top-rated movies, songs and books
This week’s daypart ratings
This month’s digital traffic data: August 2016
This month’s new media traffic data
Media supervisor opening in New York
Media buyer/planner position in Madison, WI
Digital buyer/planner opening in Madison, WI
Cincinnati agency needs a senior media strategist (online)
Senior media buyer position in San Diego