Rachel, I made a hiring mistake
The writer went to bat for a person who's turning out to be incompetent
September 28, 2012
We recently hired someone who's turning out to be a dud and I feel personally responsible because I argued for her when others had their doubts. She works for me, and while she talks a good game, she really is not very competent. I don't think she's a con artist. I think she's a bit delusional. I'm not sure what to do. My husband thinks she may grow into the job. I'm not so sure. I do know I have to do something. But what? Sign me Disappointed in New England
Some questions I get from media people are tough to answer. Yours is not.
You made a mistake. By championing her cause, you led the agency to make a mistake.
You must now fix the mistake. Go to your superiors and tell them straight out that your hire is not working out and that she needs to go, the sooner the better. Don't waste a second.
Then be as convincing as you were over her hiring to see her dismissal through.
As managers we all like to nourish the idea that under wise supervision people can grow and change.
It seldom works that way. It may work with people just starting out, where under the right direction they grow enormously over a brief period as they begin to master the particular discipline.
But for people who have been in the business for any amount of time, what you see is usually what you get. People are what they are.
If they were always late to meetings at their last job, trust that they will be late to meetings on their new job.
By the same token, if they worked independently at that last agency, and got the job done, trust that they will do so working for you.
The reason that it's important to move quickly to have her pushed out is that the longer she stays the more imbedded she will become in the department and the harder it becomes to get rid of her.
She will develop relationships. People will step in and help her, and they will grow protective of her.
But no less important, you need to move her out for her own good.
She obviously is over her head, and at some level she knows that, and that is bound to cause her discomfort and anxiety. She needs to find a job she can be good at. And it's not going to be at your agency.
This summer’s winners and losers
The future for Forbes and other business titles
Swing and a miss for the British Open
‘Manhattan,’ not a bomb but little spark
So, what’s your take on Fox-Time Warner?
For Lifetime, heels kicking up high
Cable overnights: ‘Hip Hop’ jumps on VH1
How many subscribers did Aereo have, anyway?
Right now at Comic-Con: PETA’s latest work
Study: Relevancy matters for sponsored stories
Fortune finds a new editor: Alan Murray
Fox wins Monday with two servings of Ramsay
This week’s cable ratings
- Jeff Brooks becomes chief commercial officer at Assembly
- Scott Monty becomes EVP of strategy at SHIFT Communications
- Amanda Hughes-Watkins and Crystal Ginn join Kettle
- Nick Kaplan becomes creative director at Barton F. Graf
- Andy Wright becomes publisher at The New York Times Magazine
- Tia Maggini becomes VP of original movies at Lifetime
- Megan Murphy rises to Washington bureau chief at The Financial Times
- Mark Green becomes SVP of product strategy at Simulmedia
- Brian Hallisay joins the cast of ABC's 'Revenge'
- Ed Helms, Ed Harris and Hilary Swank eyeing drama ‘One Percent’
This week’s cable ratings
This week’s broadcast ratings
This month’s new media traffic data
This week’s top movies, songs and books
This week’s daypart ratings
This week’s younger viewer ratings
Digital media planner position in Austin
Media planning supervisor job in New York
Digital media planner opening in Chicago
Assistant media buyer job in Iowa City
Media strategist position in Stamford