|
On the face of it, NBC’s “The
Apprentice” looks like a traditional reality show, right down to the
contestants being booted one by one. And you've got a big celebrity,
Donald Trump, providing the viewership push.
But when you look closer at the new program, which premieres
tonight at 8:30 after “Friends,” you find a very different sort or
reality show, one that doesn't rely on the traditional themes of sex,
romance and derring-do.
No bumps, no grinds, no swinging from vines.
This is a far more cerebral show than its promotions might suggest,
even with Donald Trump mugging about.
The idea is to pit contestants against each other in business, with
the capitalist showing the most marketplace moxie becoming Trump's protégé.
As concepts go, it's very cool-sounding, but do NBC viewers really
want to watch young Trump wannabes duking it out over who's got the best
widget?
If we spend our own days competing in the marketplace, do we want
to come home at night and watch others going at it?
Those are very big questions.
If NBC can pull it off, it could well reinvent the genre of
reality TV.
On some level, NBC is taking a big risk.
By selling “Apprentice” as the quite contradictory upscale
reality show and premiering it on a night when the network has never
resorted reality, NBC could do a big flop.
But on another level, NBC is actually turning this high-risk
show into a low-risk one with a smart bait and switch.
It’s flipping “The
Apprentice” quickly from Thursday, where it is guaranteed a strong
premiere, to Wednesday 8 p.m. the very next week, where even quirky former
time slot occupant “Ed” managed to keep the TV warm for 9 p.m. “West
Wing” and 10 p.m. “Law & Order.”
Should the Donald sputter, NBC
has Alicia Silverstone’s “Miss Match” waiting in the wings as a
replacement.
So even if it flames out, NBC, which has not launched a
mega-hit new show in years, will be no worse off. And if it succeeds, what
a nice midseason surprise.
“It’s going to be in a competitive time slot, but it should be
able to at least be competitive,” says John Rash, Campbell Mithun’s
senior vice president and director of broadcast negotiations. “Certainly
any program with Donald Trump’s name and fame associated with it
debuting on Thursday night will certainly garner at least some press, if
not some viewer attention.”
Mark Burnett (“Survivor”) will produce the show, which
lets 16 contestants ranging from MBAs to home-schooled high school grads
compete for the position of Trump protégé.
The first episode has them manning competing lemonade stands
in NYC. Most of the action focuses on the contestants, with Trump merely
popping up to fire people or offer wisdom like, “I'd much rather have a
really smart, talented guy doing a deal in a not-so-good location than an
idiot doing a deal at a great location.”
Wouldn’t we all.
The odd thing about this show, though, is that it’s not
exactly a Trump prestige vehicle a la “The Osbournes” or “The Real
Roseanne Show” or any of the other traditional celebrity voyeur shows.
And yet, with Trump attached, it doesn’t quite fit into the
genre of competition, like “Survivor” or “American Idol,” which
reward strength or talent.
It’s certainly not one of romance reality shows, like “The
Bachelor,” or romance reality with an evil twist, like “Joe
Millionaire.”
It’s not hussied up like most reality shows these days,
either. For one thing, an audience that already rejected NBC’s “Coupling”
certainly wouldn’t stand for that on Thursday.
“Apprentice” isn’t really like any reality show before
it, in fact. It’s aiming to be the first upscale reality show, where
contestants are rewarded for wit and actual business acumen is tested.
That fits with NBC’s Wednesday audience, the most affluent
on television and one you wouldn’t usually associate with reality.
“‘The Apprentice’ is on a strong night, Wednesday at 8, with
‘West Wing’ and ‘Law & Order,’ that’s a solid night for NBC
and has a pretty upscale audience that night,” Adgate says. “That
could do well among the reality shows that haven’t aired.”
At the least, “The Apprentice” just has to equal “Ed.”
Even against the return of Fox’s “American Idol” that night, it
shouldn’t be a hard task – “The Apprentice” is geared at an older
audience, perhaps even the MBA holders who missed the auditions for the
show because they had to work.
|