|
When we were kids, trading baseball cards, dolls or CD’s (I could
say vinyl albums, but then I would be dating myself) for merchandise
of equal or more personally meaningful value was the most natural
thing in the world. Barter was, after all, the original form of
trade, pre-dating currency and serving as the building block for
what evolved into today’s economic system.
Why is it, then, that the word “barter” today still
makes some brand marketers’ heads spin?
For some people, corporate barter remains a bit
mysterious. It need not be. The barter process is simpler than ever
and has proven to be a valuable tool for corporations. In
particular, trading merchandise for media is an important tool for
many companies.
The key questions are: How do you know if barter is
right for your company? And, if so, what is the process?
First, some quick background on the barter industry. It’s
been around more than 50 years in various forms, and available
industry evidence indicates that approximately 75 percent of Fortune
500 companies have used corporate trading at one time or
another.
In total, the corporate trading industry generates more
than $7.5 billion in sales annually, according to the International
Reciprocal Trade Association. These same corporate trading companies
are placing more than $1 billion in media time and space each year.
Trading credits can be used in virtually all media
segments. Media, in fact, is the most widely used form of credit
redemption, and that’s what we will examine here because of its
implications on marketing strategy.
When is barter the right way to go?
There are several situations in which barter can
be an ideal solution.
1. You have excess or slow-moving inventory from which you would
like to derive some value.
2. You have out-dated inventory on which you will likely take a
loss.
3. Your media budget is limited and you want to expand your
advertising efforts but don’t necessarily have available cash to
do so.
4. You have a building or other real estate that you would like to
sell but that isn’t worth today what you paid for it originally.
Here’s how the barter process typically
works:
The trading company receives a media plan from the client or
agency of record. The trading company’s inhouse media group then
negotiates cash and trade with media vendors. The media company, in
turn, has a broad menu of goods and services from which to fulfill
its trade portion of the buy.
The trading company submits the media buy and the
cash/trade blend to the client or agency of record for approval.
Once approved, the media buy is executed and the trading company
provides industry standard post delivery.
If barter appears to be a solution for your company,
how do you select the right commercial trading company – the right
partner – with which to work?
Like anything else, there is no substitute for due
diligence. In this case, in particular, doing some basic homework is
especially important since this is an area that is new to you.
Here are some key questions to ask a trading
company when you are seeking a partner:
Speak to the company’s media buying staff and
ask about their credentials. This is no different than hiring a
media buying firm. You want to know that you will be dealing with
media professionals who could easily be doing planning for a
traditional ad agency, and not people who are simply trying to move
the media they have regardless of your marketing goals.
Ask for examples of the media available to you to
ensure that high quality options are available for consideration.
Ask for client references and case studies. You don’t
want to be a guinea pig.
How willing is the trading company to involve your
agency in the process? The barter firm should be 100 percent willing
to review media schedules with your agency (more on the barter
company-agency dynamic in a moment).
The company should be willing to guarantee the buy they
will make for you and ultimately offer proof-of-performance
verification.
What happens after your goods are acquired by the
trading company is also important. Find out where the company plans
to sell your merchandise.
This is an often-overlooked element of the process, but
a very important one because you do not want to denigrate your
brand. All reputable trading companies will stipulate in writing
that they will adhere to your guidelines concerning remarketing your
goods.
The barter company/ad agency dynamic alluded to above
is one that sometimes throws a monkey wrench into the works. Many
agencies initially will express a resistance to barter because they
see it as a threat to commissions or as a loss of control.
You as the client must make sure that your agency
supports your decision to use barter and is serious about working
with your barter partner. Only then can the process achieve your
goals.
Today, media services are contracted a la carte. You
may chose agencies under different corporate umbrellas because you
are confident that each will provide the best expertise.
The same is true when selecting a trading company. The
trading company is not replacing the agency; it is simply bringing a
different skill set to the table.
As we intuitively knew when we were kids, barter is a logical
and beneficial tool to get something that you can use in exchange
for something you cannot.
In the world of business, barter need not be much more
complicated or mysterious than trading baseball cards-- if you know
the right questions to ask.
|