Little lasting power
for 'Last Comic Standing'

Interest wanes the younger the viewing audience

By Toni Fitzgerald

   Each of the past three weeks, NBC has debuted one new reality show. Each week, that show has premiered to strong numbers, only to wilt significantly in its second outing.
   Exhibits A and B are “Fame” and “For Love or Money,” both of which lost at least 12 percent of their 18-49 and 18-34 audiences in their second week.
   “Last Comic Standing” has become the latest to join them.
   In its debut last week, “Last” placed in the top 10 among 18-49s and 18-34s and top 20 among 18-24s.
   The show’s numbers were slightly lower than “Love’s” the previous week. While “Love” premiered with a 4.9 among 18-34s and a 3.8 among 18-24s, “Last” registered a 4.3 and 3.0 in those demos.
   The younger the demo, the less interested they were in in the Jay Mohr-hosted“Last.” It placed No. 25 among 12-24s, tying with MTV’s “Road Rules XII,” and didn’t even rank among 9-14s or 2-11s.
   In week two, this past Tuesday, “Last” dipped 20 percent among 18-49s to a 3.6 rating. It still managed to win its time slot among adults 18-34 and men 18-49. And it’s holding on better than “Dog Eat Dog,” a second-season summer show that airs at 8 p.m. Tuesday.
   “Last” improved on its “Dog Eat Dog” lead-in by 25 percent this past Tuesday. In its second half-hour, it peaked at a 3.9 adult 18-49 rating.
   Fox’s “American Juniors” remained a top-five choice among 9-14s, 12-17s and 12-24s last week, despite fading mightily among older demographics. It’s possible but not certain that the start of the judging portion of the contest will draw in more viewers the next few weeks.
   The last game of the NBA playoffs on ABC ranked No. 1 among 18-24s, the only demographic in which it topped the chart.
   Among 12-17s and 9-14s, the game didn’t even rank in the top 15.
   Nickelodeon had all of the top 30 among 2-11s. Cable networks held 10 of the top 15 spots among 9-14s.
   For only the second time this season, cable had the top-ranked show among 9-14s, Nick’s Saturday morning “SpongeBob, SquarePants.” That show was also No. 1 among 9-14s in the third week of March.

TOP 30 PROGRAMS - BROADCAST & CABLE TV
Adults 18-49
Week Ending June 15


Rank

Program

Net

Rtg%

In Millions

1

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 6(S)-06/15/2003

ABC

5.0

6.41

2

CSI

CBS

5.0

6.41

3

DATELINE 6/9(S)-06/09/2003

NBC

4.8

6.17

4

EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND

CBS

4.7

6.06

5

FRIENDS

NBC

4.7

6.06

6

WILL & GRACE

NBC

4.7

5.98

7

CSI: MIAMI

CBS

4.6

5.95

8

LAST COMIC STANDING

NBC

4.5

5.82

9

LAW AND ORDER

NBC

4.3

5.50

10

FOR LOVE OR MONEY

NBC

4.2

5.41

11

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 4(S)-06/11/2003

ABC

4.2

5.35

12

STILL STANDING

CBS

4.1

5.32

13

SCRUBS

NBC

4.0

5.20

14

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 5(S)-06/13/2003

ABC

3.8

4.85

15

WITHOUT A TRACE

CBS

3.7

4.80

16

ACCORDING TO JIM 9PM

ABC

3.7

4.77

17

LAW AND ORDER WED 9PM

NBC

3.7

4.75

18

FRASIER-THU 9:30P

NBC

3.6

4.69

19

LAW AND ORDER:SVU

NBC

3.5

4.52

20

THAT '70S SHOW

FOX

3.5

4.52

21

AMERICAN JUNIORS-TUES

FOX

3.5

4.50

22

BERNIE MAC

FOX

3.4

4.43

23

48 HOURS INVESTIGATES

CBS

3.4

4.41

24

ABC STANLEY CUP FINAL-GM7(S)-06/09/2003

ABC

3.4

4.37

25

SIMPSONS

FOX

3.4

4.37

26

SIMPSONS SPECIAL(S)-06/11/2003

FOX

3.3

4.27

27

KING OF QUEENS

CBS

3.3

4.23

28

YES, DEAR

CBS

3.3

4.22

29

TEST THE NATION(S)-06/09/2003

FOX

3.2

4.13

30

FOX NASCAR WINSTON CUP

FOX

3.2

4.13

Source: MTV Networks, based on data from Nielsen Media Research



TOP 30 PROGRAMS - BROADCAST & CABLE TV
Adults 18-34
Week Ending June 15


Rank

Program

Net

Rtg%

In Millions

1

FRIENDS

NBC

5.1

3.30

2

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 6(S)-06/15/2003

ABC

4.7

3.06

3

SCRUBS

NBC

4.6

2.99

4

WILL & GRACE

NBC

4.6

2.96

5

SIMPSONS

FOX

4.4

2.87

6

SIMPSONS SPECIAL(S)-06/11/2003

FOX

4.3

2.81

7

LAST COMIC STANDING

NBC

4.3

2.78

8

THAT '70S SHOW

FOX

4.1

2.65

9

BERNIE MAC

FOX

4.1

2.65

9

FOR LOVE OR MONEY

NBC

4.1

2.65

11

DATELINE 6/9(S)-06/09/2003

NBC

4.1

2.63

12

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 4(S)-06/11/2003

ABC

4.0

2.61

13

CSI

CBS

4.0

2.61

14

KING OF THE HILL 2

FOX

3.9

2.50

15

AMERICAN JUNIORS-TUES

FOX

3.8

2.46

16

TEST THE NATION(S)-06/09/2003

FOX

3.7

2.37

17

LAW AND ORDER

NBC

3.5

2.28

18

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 5(S)-06/13/2003

ABC

3.5

2.25

19

MALCOLM IN THE MIDDLE

FOX

3.5

2.24

20

CSI: MIAMI

CBS

3.3

2.13

21

ABC STANLEY CUP FINAL-GM7(S)-06/09/2003

ABC

3.3

2.12

22

FRASIER-THU 9:30P

NBC

3.1

2.01

23

SATURDAY NIGHT

NBC

3.1

1.98

24

EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND

CBS

3.0

1.97

25

LAW AND ORDER WED 9PM

NBC

3.0

1.96

26

CEDRIC ENTERTAINER: PRESN

FOX

3.0

1.92

27

DOG EAT DOG

NBC

2.8

1.83

28

ACCORDING TO JIM 9PM

ABC

2.8

1.81

29

WITHOUT A TRACE

CBS

2.8

1.79

30

WWE SMACKDOWN!

TNN

2.8

1.78

Source: MTV Networks, based on data from Nielsen Media Research



TOP 30 PROGRAMS - BROADCAST & CABLE TV
Adults 18-24
Week Ending June 15


Rank

Program

Net

Rtg%

In Millions

1

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 6(S)-06/15/2003

ABC

5.1

1.36

2

SIMPSONS SPECIAL(S)-06/11/2003

FOX

4.7

1.27

3

BERNIE MAC

FOX

4.1

1.09

4

SIMPSONS

FOX

3.8

1.02

5

THAT '70S SHOW

FOX

3.7

0.99

6

FRIENDS

NBC

3.6

0.97

7

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 4(S)-06/11/2003

ABC

3.6

0.96

8

KING OF THE HILL 2

FOX

3.5

0.95

9

AMERICAN JUNIORS-TUES

FOX

3.5

0.95

10

SCRUBS

NBC

3.5

0.94

11

WILL & GRACE

NBC

3.4

0.92

12

TEST THE NATION(S)-06/09/2003

FOX

3.3

0.89

13

FOR LOVE OR MONEY

NBC

3.3

0.88

14

MALCOLM IN THE MIDDLE

FOX

3.2

0.87

15

CSI

CBS

3.2

0.86

16

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 5(S)-06/13/2003

ABC

3.1

0.83

17

LAST COMIC STANDING

NBC

3.0

0.81

18

30 SECONDS TO FAME

FOX

2.9

0.79

19

REAL WORLD XIII

MTV

2.9

0.77

20

STPD BHVR: CAUGHT ON TAPE

FOX

2.8

0.76

21

SATURDAY NIGHT

NBC

2.8

0.76

22

ABC STANLEY CUP FINAL-GM7(S)-06/09/2003

ABC

2.8

0.75

23

REBA - WB

WB

2.8

0.74

24

REBA-6/13-WB(S)-06/13/2003

WB

2.7

0.74

25

WWE SMACKDOWN!

UPN

2.7

0.73

26

OSBOURNES

MTV

2.6

0.71

27

WHAT I LIKE ABOUT YOU-WB

WB

2.6

0.71

28

DATELINE 6/9(S)-06/09/2003

NBC

2.6

0.69

29

CSI: MIAMI

CBS

2.6

0.69

30

ACCORDING TO JIM 9PM

ABC

2.6

0.69

Source: MTV Networks, based on data from Nielsen Media Research



TOP 30 PROGRAMS - BROADCAST & CABLE TV
People 12-24
Week Ending June 15


Rank

Program

Net

Rtg%

In Millions

1

SIMPSONS SPECIAL(S)-06/11/2003

FOX

4.0

2.07

2

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 6(S)-06/15/2003

ABC

3.9

2.04

3

SIMPSONS

FOX

3.9

2.03

4

AMERICAN JUNIORS-TUES

FOX

3.7

1.94

5

KING OF THE HILL 2

FOX

3.5

1.79

6

BERNIE MAC

FOX

3.4

1.74

7

MALCOLM IN THE MIDDLE

FOX

3.3

1.72

8

THAT '70S SHOW

FOX

3.1

1.58

9

REAL WORLD XIII

MTV

3.1

1.58

10

WWE SMACKDOWN!

UPN

3.0

1.56

11

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 4(S)-06/11/2003

ABC

3.0

1.56

12

TEST THE NATION(S)-06/09/2003

FOX

2.9

1.51

13

OLIVER BEENE

FOX

2.9

1.50

14

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 5(S)-06/13/2003

ABC

2.9

1.49

15

FRIENDS

NBC

2.7

1.41

16

WILL & GRACE

NBC

2.7

1.40

17

FOR LOVE OR MONEY

NBC

2.7

1.39

18

YU-GI-OH - WB

WB

2.7

1.37

19

OSBOURNES

MTV

2.6

1.37

20

ABC STANLEY CUP FINAL-GM7(S)-06/09/2003

ABC

2.6

1.37

21

30 SECONDS TO FAME

FOX

2.6

1.33

22

SCRUBS

NBC

2.6

1.32

23

STPD BHVR: CAUGHT ON TAPE

FOX

2.5

1.31

24

CSI

CBS

2.5

1.31

25

LAST COMIC STANDING

NBC

2.5

1.28

26

ROAD RULES XII

MTV

2.5

1.28

27

SATURDAY NIGHT

NBC

2.4

1.26

28

REBA-6/13-WB(S)-06/13/2003

WB

2.4

1.22

29

FAMILY GUY

TOON

2.4

1.22

30

ACCORDING TO JIM 9PM

ABC

2.3

1.21

Source: MTV Networks, based on data from Nielsen Media Research 



TOP 30 PROGRAMS - BROADCAST & CABLE TV
Teens 12-17
Week Ending June 15


Rank

Program

Net

Rtg%

In Millions

1

AMERICAN JUNIORS-TUES

FOX

4.0

1.00

2

2003 MOVIE AWARDS

MTV

4.0

0.99

3

SIMPSONS

FOX

4.0

0.99

4

FOX MOVIE-SPECIAL(S)-06/02/2003

FOX

3.4

0.85

5

THAT '70S SHOW SPC(S)-06/04/2003

FOX

3.4

0.84

6

MALCOLM IN THE MIDDLE

FOX

3.4

0.84

7

KING OF THE HILL 2

FOX

3.3

0.83

8

MISS UNIVERSE PAGEANT.(S)-06/03/2003

NBC

3.3

0.81

9

BERNIE MAC

FOX

3.2

0.80

10

OLIVER BEENE

FOX

3.1

0.77

11

2003 MOVIE AWARDS POST SH

MTV

3.1

0.77

12

KING OF THE HILL

FOX

2.8

0.69

13

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 1(S)-06/04/2003

ABC

2.7

0.68

14

KEEN EDDIE

FOX

2.7

0.67

15

30 SECONDS TO FAME

FOX

2.7

0.66

16

CEDRIC ENTERTAINER: PRESN

FOX

2.7

0.66

17

FUTURAMA

FOX

2.6

0.66

18

THAT '70S SHOW

FOX

2.6

0.65

19

WWE ENTERTAINMENT

TNN

2.5

0.63

20

STATIC SHOCK - WB

WB

2.5

0.63

21

DOG EAT DOG

NBC

2.5

0.63

22

YUYU HAKUSHO/KA

TOON

2.5

0.62

23

NBA FINALS ON ABC-GM 3(S)-06/08/2003

ABC

2.5

0.62

24

MEGAMAN - WB

WB

2.5

0.61

25

POKEMON - WB

WB

2.5

0.61

26

WWE ENTERTAINMENT

TNN

2.4

0.60

27

YU-GI-OH - WB

WB

2.4

0.60

28

FOR LOVE OR MONEY

NBC

2.4

0.60

29

STPD BHVR: CAUGHT ON TAPE

FOX

2.4

0.60

30

FEAR FACTOR

NBC

2.4

0.60

Source: MTV Networks, based on data from Nielsen Media Research



TOP 30 PROGRAMS - BROADCAST & CABLE TV
Kids 9-14
Week Ending June
15


Rank

Program

Net

Rtg%

In Millions

1

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.3

1.32

2

YU-GI-OH - WB

WB

5.1

1.28

3

AMERICAN JUNIORS-TUES

FOX

5.0

1.25

4

FAIRLY ODD PARENTS

NICK

4.9

1.23

5

FAIRLY ODD PARENTS

NICK

4.7

1.18

6

JIMMY NEUTRON

NICK

4.6

1.16

7

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.5

1.14

8

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.3

1.09

9

POKEMON - WB

WB

4.3

1.07

10

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.3

1.07

11

FAIRLY ODD PARENTS

NICK

4.2

1.06

12

SIMPSONS

FOX

4.0

1.01

13

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.0

1.01

14

MALCOLM IN THE MIDDLE

FOX

4.0

1.00

15

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.0

1.00

16

HEY ARNOLD

NICK

4.0

1.00

17

MEGAMAN - WB

WB

3.9

0.99

18

JIMMY NEUTRON

NICK

3.9

0.98

19

OLIVER BEENE

FOX

3.9

0.98

20

SPONGEBOB

NICK

3.8

0.96

21

ROCKET POWER

NICK

3.7

0.94

22

FAIRLY ODD PARENTS

NICK

3.7

0.92

23

FAIRLY ODD PARENTS

NICK

3.7

0.92

24

JIMMY NEUTRON

NICK

3.5

0.89

25

SPONGEBOB

NICK

3.5

0.88

26

JACKIE CHAN ADV - WB

WB

3.5

0.88

27

HEY ARNOLD

NICK

3.5

0.88

28

SPONGEBOB

NICK

3.5

0.88

29

KING OF THE HILL 2

FOX

3.5

0.87

30

ROCKET POWER

NICK

3.4

0.86

Source: MTV Networks, based on data from Nielsen Media Research



TOP 30 PROGRAMS - BROADCAST & CABLE TV
Kids 2-11
Week Ending
June 15


Rank

Program

Net

Rtg%

In Millions

1

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.8

2.31

2

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.5

2.21

3

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.5

2.19

4

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.4

2.17

5

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.4

2.16

6

FAIRLY ODD PARENTS

NICK

5.3

2.11

7

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.2

2.10

8

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.2

2.07

9

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.1

2.06

10

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.1

2.05

11

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.1

2.05

12

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.1

2.03

13

SPONGEBOB

NICK

5.1

2.02

14

JIMMY NEUTRON

NICK

5.0

2.00

15

RUGRATS

NICK

5.0

2.00

16

THE AMANDA SHOW

NICK

4.9

1.96

17

THE AMANDA SHOW

NICK

4.9

1.95

18

CHALKZONE

NICK

4.9

1.95

19

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.8

1.94

20

ROCKET POWER

NICK

4.8

1.93

21

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.8

1.90

22

DORA THE EXPLORER

NICK

4.7

1.89

23

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.7

1.88

24

RUGRATS

NICK

4.7

1.86

24

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.7

1.86

26

SPONGEBOB

NICK

4.6

1.85

27

THE AMANDA SHOW

NICK

4.6

1.83

28

JIMMY NEUTRON

NICK

4.6

1.83

29

BLUES CLUES

NICK

4.6

1.82

30

THE AMANDA SHOW

NICK

4.6

1.82

Source: MTV Networks, based on data from Nielsen Media Research


June 20, 2003© 2003 Media Life


-Toni Fitzgerald is a staff writer for Media Life.


Printer-Friendly Version |  Send to a Friend
Cover Page | Contact Us

Click here to add the Media Life home page to your favorites!