How ABC fumbled
its Super Bowl edge

Great post-game time slot. But 'Alias?' Bummer.

By Toni Fitzgerald

   No time slot may be as dear to TV programmers as the one after Super Bowl, a fact CBS well appreciated two years when it aired "Survivor: The Australian Outback" to a huge audience. 
   Last Sunday, ABC, though no less aware of the advantage, chose to air a show with a far less broad appeal, the cult favorite "Alias." It was a gamble intended to expose a new army of viewers to the critically acclaimed show.
   Call it a major programming fumble.
   “Alias” had the lowest ratings of any post-game show since at least 1987, even though sexy star Jennifer Garner appeared in bra and underwear in several promotions during the game.
   The episode pulled 17.4 million viewers, twice its normal audience, but nearly 30 million fewer than "Survivor" hauled in two years ago.
    ABC did not help its case by airing the special "Alias" episode at 11 p.m., more than 40 minutes after the game ended, for the latest post-Super Bowl program start in history.
    Instead it chose to air 40 minutes of post-game coverage, effectively clearing living rooms across America of anything by diehard football fans.
   And that’s too bad for ABC, which saw this as a chance to introduce the critically acclaimed but ratings-challenged “Alias” to a broader audience.
   The show’s audience of about 9.3 million per week is down 9 percent from last year. The network made series creator J.J. Abrams promise that, if it aired “Alias” in the post-Super Bowl slot, future episodes would be more self-contained, less cliffhanger-driven and thus more viewer-friendly. In essence, “Alias” will be dumbed down.
   Sunday’s broadcast did haul “Alias’” biggest audience ever. But that was a far cry from even Fox’s disappointing “Malcolm” episode last year (21 million) or “Survivor: The Australian Outback” (45 million).
   Even ABC’s last post-Super Bowl special, “The Practice,” fared better. “The Practice” retained 27 percent of its lead-in despite a lower game rating than this year. “Alias” retained only 19 percent.
   No previous post-Super Bowl show had ever scored a single-digit rating among 18-49s, not even ABC’s “Extreme” back in 1995.
   “Alias” doubled its usual Sunday night 18-49 adult rating to an 8.3. That tells you why ABC wanted this program to get a ratings boost.
   Maybe fans just aren’t ready for a primetime broadcast female action hero. By not tuning in after the Super Bowl, non-“Alias” fans seemed to offer a resounding no thank you. Yet by delaying the start until 11 p.m., ABC has no one to blame but itself.
   There was some cheerier news for the network. With terrific numbers for the actual game, ABC finished No. 1 among households and 18-49s for the week. Its season-to-date 18-49 average jumped from 3.8 last week to a third-place 4.1 this week -- a good thing, too, because fourth-place Fox is also surging.
   The return of “American Idol” boosted Fox to second last week among 18-49s. Fox had the four highest-rated non-football shows among 18-49s last week with three “American Idols” and a “Joe Millionaire.”
   Fox’s impressive 5.6 weekly primetime average would have won a non-Super Bowl week. It’s the best non-playoffs weekly 18-49 average of the season on any network. Only Fox’s World Series-enhanced 5.6 in late October has matched it. The next-highest average was a November 5.1 by NBC.
   Speaking of NBC, its halftime “Saturday Night Live” special was a ratings dud. The show attracted a 2.5 18-49 rating. Last year’s “Fear Factor” special starring the Playboy Playmates drew a 4.6.

PRIMETIME AVERAGES BY NETWORK
Ranked on Households
Week Ending Jan. 26, 2003

Network

Households*

People 2+

Adults 18-49

Rtg%

(000)

Shr

Rtg%

(000)

Shr

Rtg%

(000)

Shr

ABC

11.7

12470

18

8.3

22510

20

9.1

11770

22

CBS

7.2

7670

11

3.9

10690

9

3.0

3920

7

FOX

7.1

7600

11

4.5

12190

10

5.6

7150

13

NBC

6.6

7060

10

3.7

9990

9

4.0

5150

10

WB

2.5

2700

4

1.5

3990

3

1.8

2260

4

UPN

2.1

2270

3

1.2

3390

3

1.5

1920

4

PAX

0.8

890

1

0.4

1140

1

0.3

330

1

* Each rating point is equivalent to 1.067 million homes
Source: Nielsen Media Research


SEASON-TO-DATE PRIMETIME
 AVERAGES BY NETWORK
Ranked on Households
Week Ending Jan. 26

Network

Households*

People 2+

Adults 18-49 

Rtg%

(000)

Shr

Rtg%

(000)

Shr

Rtg%

(000)

Shr

CBS

8.4

8960

14

4.7

12800

12

4.0

5120

11

NBC

7.8

8320

13

4.3

11800

11

4.5

5850

12

ABC

6.7

7170

11

4.0

10770

10

4.1

5300

11

FOX

5.8

6160

9

3.4

9320

9

3.8

4910

10

WB

2.7

2860

4

1.6

4300

4

1.8

2370

5

UPN

2.4

2510

4

1.4

3750

3

1.6

2050

4

PAX

0.9

930

1

0.5

1230

1

0.3

400

1

* Each rating point is equivalent to 1.067 million homes
Source: Nielsen Media Research


NETWORK TV
Ranked on Households
Week Ending Jan. 26, 2003

#

PROGRAMS

Net

HOUSEHOLDS

PERSONS 2+

Rtg%

Shr

(000)

RANK

Rtg%

(000)

1

SUPER BOWL XXXVII(S)

ABC

40.7

61

43433

1

32.6

88637

2

SUPER BOWL POST GUN(S)

ABC

33.1

50

35361

2

26.3

71634

3

SUPER BOWL POST GAME(S)

ABC

23.4

38

25007

3

17.7

48192

4

CSI

CBS

15.2

23

16236

6

9.0

24459

5

AMERICAN IDOL-TUESDAY

FOX

14.3

21

15274

4

9.7

26502

6

AMERICAN IDOL-WEDNESDAY

FOX

13.8

20

14776

5

9.2

24915

7

AMERICAN IDOL SPECIAL(S)

FOX

13.1

19

14027

7

8.7

23599

8

JOE MILLIONAIRE

FOX

11.5

17

12299

8

6.9

18821

9

LAW AND ORDER

NBC

11.1

18

11826

9

6.1

16603

10

FRIENDS

NBC

11.0

17

11731

9

6.1

16649

10

LAW AND ORDER:SVU

NBC

11.0

19

11789

11

5.9

16081

12

EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND

CBS

10.5

15

11198

11

5.9

15925

13

WITHOUT A TRACE

CBS

10.4

17

11104

13

5.7

15496

14

CSI: MIAMI

CBS

9.8

16

10409

16

5.3

14399

15

SCRUBS

NBC

9.7

14

10297

19

5.2

14087

16

JAG

CBS

9.5

14

10128

16

5.3

14304

16

JUDGING AMY

CBS

9.5

15

10088

22

4.9

13398

18

KING OF QUEENS

CBS

9.4

14

10071

19

5.2

14197

18

STAR SEARCH

CBS

9.4

14

10059

15

5.5

14862

18

YES, DEAR

CBS

9.4

14

10012

16

5.3

14469

21

FEAR FACTOR

NBC

8.8

13

9419

13

5.7

15537

21

PRIMETIME THURSDAY

ABC

8.8

14

9408

25

4.7

12660

23

WILL & GRACE

NBC

8.7

13

9275

27

4.5

12277

24

BACHELORETTE, THE

ABC

8.5

13

9071

22

4.9

13391

25

GUARDIAN, THE

CBS

8.4

12

8917

28

4.4

11902

25

STAR SEARCH-WED

CBS

8.4

13

8940

22

4.9

13406

Source: Nielsen Media Research


TOP 30 PROGRAMS - BROADCAST & CABLE TV
Adults 18-49
Week Ending Jan. 26, 2003

Rank

Program

Net

Adults 18-49
Rtg%

In Millions

1

SUPER BOWL XXXVII(S)-1/26

ABC

36.4

46.86

2

SUPER BOWL POST GUN(S)-1/26

ABC

31.0

39.90

3

SUPER BOWL KICK-OFF III(S)-1/26

ABC

24.2

31.09

4

SUPER BOWL POST GAME(S)-1/26

ABC

21.0

27.01

5

AMERICAN IDOL-TUESDAY

FOX

12.4

15.90

6

AMERICAN IDOL-WEDNESDAY

FOX

11.8

15.20

7

AMERICAN IDOL SPECIAL(S)-1/21

FOX

11.3

14.49

8

JOE MILLIONAIRE

FOX

10.0

12.82

9

CSI

CBS

8.4

10.86

10

ALIAS SPECIAL-1/26(S)-1/26

ABC

8.2

10.59

11

FRIENDS

NBC

7.9

10.18

12

SCRUBS

NBC

7.1

9.08

13

MEET MY FOLKS 1/20(S)-1/20

NBC

6.7

8.63

14

FEAR FACTOR

NBC

6.5

8.40

15

WILL & GRACE

NBC

6.4

8.22

16

GOOD MORNING MIAMI

NBC

6.0

7.77

17

LAW AND ORDER

NBC

6.0

7.76

18

THAT '70S SHOW

FOX

6.0

7.74

19

BACHELORETTE, THE

ABC

6.0

7.74

20

MEET MY FOLKS 1/21(S)-1/21

NBC

5.6

7.17

21

LAW AND ORDER:SVU

NBC

5.5

7.13

22

YES, DEAR

CBS

5.4

6.95

23

FEAR FACTOR 1/20(S)-1/20

NBC

5.3

6.87

24

EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND

CBS

5.2

6.64

25

PRIMETIME THURSDAY

ABC

5.1

6.59

26

WITHOUT A TRACE

CBS

5.1

6.50

27

CELEBRITY MOLE HAWAII

ABC

5.1

6.49

28

CSI: MIAMI

CBS

5.0

6.42

29

KING OF QUEENS

CBS

4.9

6.28

30

STAR SEARCH

CBS

4.8

6.18

Source: MTV Networks, based on data from Nielsen Media Research


CABLE TV
Ranked on Households
Week Ending Jan. 19

BASIC CABLE

#

PROGRAM NAME

NET

Households

Persons 2+

(000)

Rtg%

(000)

1

TNT ORIGINAL(S)-1/17 (MONTE WALSH)

TNT

4914

4.6

7516

2

TRADING SPACES

TLC

3758

3.5

5926

3

TNT ORIGINAL(S)-1/18 (MONTE WALSH)

TNT

3493

3.3

5234

4

WWE ENTERTAINMENT (WWE RAW ZONE)

TNN

3427

3.2

4903

5

NBA REGULAR SEASON FRI L (LAKERS/ROCKETS)

ESPN

3326

3.1

4882

6

WWE ENTERTAINMENT (WWE RAW)

TNN

3288

3.1

4573

7

PRIME MOVIE (HUNGER POINT)

LIF

2968

2.8

3983

8

SPONGEBOB

NICK

2905

2.7

4101

9

JIMMY NEUTRON

NICK

2872

2.7

3959

10

FAIRLY ODD PARENTS

NICK

2818

2.6

3952

11

SATURDAY MOVIE (A MARRIAGE OF CONVENIENCE)

LIF

2766

2.6

3167

12

SPONGEBOB

NICK

2698

2.5

3792

13

MOVIE, USA (NEXT FRIDAY)

USA

2627

2.5

3891

14

REAL WORLD XII

MTV

2623

2.5

3652

15

SPONGEBOB

NICK

2593

2.4

3806

PAY CABLE

#

PROGRAM NAME

NET

Households

Persons 2+

(000)

Rtg%

(000)

1

ROLLING STONES LIVE

HBO

2283

2.1

3383

2

TRAINING DAY

HBO

2204

2.1

3023

3

SHOCK VIDEO 2002 (AU)

HBO

2086

2.0

2633

4

TAXICAB CONFESSIONS 2003

HBO

1979

1.9

2856

5

WALK TO REMEMBER, A

HBO

1920

1.8

2686

Total U.S. ratings and household projections are based on 106.7 million TV homes.
Source: Nielsen Media Research


SYNDICATION
Ranked on Households
Week Ending Jan. 12

#

PROGRAMS

Syndicator

Households

US Rtg%

(000)

1

WHEEL OF FORTUNE

KIN

9.9

10577

2

FRIENDS-SYN (AT)

WB

7.9

8376

3

SEINFELD (AT)

SPT

7.8

8274

3

JEOPARDY

KIN

7.8

8270

5

EVRY LVS RAYMOND-SYN (AT)

KIN

6.6

7017

6

SEINFELD-WKND (AT)

SPT

6.2

6620

7

ENTERTAINMENT TONIGHT(AT)

PRM

5.8

6220

8

OPRAH WINFREY SHOW (AT)

KIN

5.7

6051

9

JUDGE JUDY (AT)

PRM

5.6

5968

10

DR. PHIL SHOW

KIN

4.8

5074

Source: Nielsen Media Research


SPANISH-LANGUAGE TELEVISION
Ranked on Households
Week Ending Jan. 26

#

PROGRAMS

Net

NHTI*
Rtg%

Projection
(000)

1

ENTRE EL AMOR Y ODIO MON

UNI

25.5

2480

2

VIAS DEL AMOR MON

UNI

25.2

2453

2

VIAS DEL AMOR WED

UNI

25.2

2448

4

SUPER BOWL POST GUN(S)-1/26

ABC

25.1

2440

5

VIAS DEL AMOR TUE

UNI

24.3

2362

6

ENTRE EL AMOR Y ODIO TUE

UNI

24.1

2347

7

VIAS DEL AMOR THU

UNI

23.9

2323

8

ENTRE EL AMOR Y ODIO WED

UNI

23.8

2315

9

ENTRE EL AMOR Y ODIO THU

UNI

23.1

2243

10

GATA SALVAJE-THU

UNI

22.7

2212

11

CRISTINA-MON

UNI

22.5

2191

12

GATA SALVAJE-WED

UNI

21.8

2123

13

GATA SALVAJE-MON

UNI

21.7

2107

14

ENTRE EL AMOR Y ODIO FRI

UNI

21.0

2045

15

GATA SALVAJE-TUE

UNI

20.9

2032

16

VIAS DEL AMOR FRI

UNI

20.6

2005

17

CASOS VIDA R: ED. ESP FRI

UNI

19.5

1899

18

GATA SALVAJE-FRI

UNI

18.7

1816

19

DON FRANCISCO PRESENTA-WE

UNI

18.4

1786

20

PICA Y SE EXTIENDE TUE

UNI

16.3

1587

* Nielsen Hispanic Television Index; ratings based on 9.7 million Hispanic TV homes.
Source: Nielsen Media Research


NETWORK SPORTS
Ranked on Households
Week Ending Jan. 19, 2003

#

PROGRAMS

Net

Episode

Households

Persons 2+

US Rtg%

Shr

(000)

(000)

1

AFC CHAMPIONSHIP
(S)-1/19

CBS

TENN. AT OAK

24.6

38

26243

41456

2

NFC CHAMPIONSHIP
(S)-1/19

FOX

TAMPA BAY AT PHILA

23.8

45

25392

38741

3

AFC CHMP POST GAME
(S)-1/19

CBS

TENN.  AT OAK

13.2

20

14038

21029

4

NFC
 CHAMPIONSHIP
-PRE(S)
1/19

FOX

TAMPA BAY AT PHILA

8.6

21

9179

12457

5

NFC CHAMPIONSHIP-POST
(S)-1/19

FOX

TAMPA BAY AT PHILA

7.6

13

8137

12103

6

AFC CHAMPIONSHIP PRE-GAME
(S)-1/19

CBS

6.5

11

6947

10703

7

U.S. FIGURE SKTNG CH-8PM
(S)-1/18

ABC

6.0

10

6366

9020

8

WWE SMACKDOWN!

UPN

3.4

5

3627

5344

9

U.S. FIGURE SKTNG CH-4PM
(S)-1/18

ABC

3.0

7

3217

4213

10

CHEVY SKATING SPECT
(S)-1/19

ABC

3.0

6

3230

3990

11

FOX NFL SATURDAY NIGHT
(S)-1/18

FOX

2.5

4

2688

4041

12

ABC NCAA BASKETBALL
SAT.

ABC

DUKE AT MD
/AZ AT UCLA

2.0

5

2105

2767

13

NCAA BBALL
SAT-2

CBS

ILL AT IND

2.0

5

2145

2740

14

ABC NCAA BSKTBL POST-SAT
.(B)-1/18

ABC

DUKE AT MD

1.5

4

1555

1978

15

NCAA BBAL
-SAT-1

CBS

NOTRE DAME AT KTY

1.4

4

1456

2016

16

NBC SPORTS SPECIL
(S)-1/18

NBC

1.1

3

1192

1573

17

NBA INSIDE STUFF

ABC

1.0

3

1040

1274

18

UNDER 
THE HELMET

FOX

1.0

3

1033

1248

19

NBC SPORTS SPECIL
(S)-1/18

NBC

1.0

2

1072

1338

20

PGA SPECIAL
(S)-1/18

NBC

0.8

2

826

1085

Source: Nielsen Media Research

January 29, 2003© 2003 Media Life


-Toni Fitzgerald is a staff writer for Media Life


Printer-Friendly Version |  Send to a Friend
Cover Page | Contact Us