Media Life
Homepage



TV Review

'The State Within,'
Brits' thinking '24'


BBC three-parter is first a fast-paced thriller

Feb 16, 2007

Calling the new BBC America miniseries “The State Within” a British version of “24” might be a slight oversimplification but only a slight one. While the three-part thriller, which premieres tomorrow night at 9, is different from its American counterpart in fundamental ways, they are at least cousins, if not siblings.

And that's mostly a good thing. Using the conspiracy thriller template and replacing “24’s” kitchen-sink approach with a more spare, reserved storytelling style is a clever conceit.

More often than not, it makes for compelling drama that largely skirts past the eye-rolling, over-the-top twists that occasionally muddy up “24.”

Of course, the flip side is that while “24” is a non-stop adrenalin rush, “The State Within” is inclined to sink into broodiness, allowing the thriller element to give way to sloggy discussions of the death penalty and the dangers of race-based profiling.

And sometimes "State" is just too complicated for its own good.

But despite those shortcomings, the series proves to be compelling television, anchored in the anxiety of believable threats and fortified by quality work from a strong cast, especially lead actor, Jason Isaacs, who knows the difference between playing a hero and a superhero.

Isaacs is Sir Mark Brydon, the British Ambassador to the U.S. Back in Washington after a trip to London, he is leaving Dulles Airport when another plane explodes just after takeoff.

When it’s revealed that the bombing may have been the work of a British Muslim, Brydon must concurrently attempt to uncover the truth about the incident even as he tries to pacify livid representatives of the American government.

Foremost among those angry Yanks is Defense Secretary Lynne Warner (Sharon Gless, “Cagney and Lacey”). Brydon enlists the help of Nicholas Brocklehurst (Ben Daniels, “Cutting It”), the embassy’s intelligence officer.

Meanwhile, in a seemingly unrelated plotline (which of course means it’s not), former British soldier Luke Gardner (Lennie James, “Jericho”) is on death row for murdering two girls. Trying to save him is Jane Lavery (Eva Birthistle, “Silent Witness”), a government human rights lawyer.

The performances are uniformly solid. Daniels makes for an appropriately menacing MI6 man. And James, as a man marked for death in mere days, makes Luke a prickly mix of bitterness and tortured loyalty. James refuses to let Luke sink into saintliness.

But the real star of the series is Isaacs. He’s proven he can play dark characters, like the vicious, small-time Boston mobster in the Showtime series “Brotherhood.”

But here he does something very different. His Mark Brydon is an ambitious man, a rising political star, who over the years has let expediency replace conscience as he moved up in the diplomatic corps.

Only now, in a moment of personal and political crisis, is he rediscovering that conscience.

Isaacs makes that transition convincing, even poignant, especially amid all the chaos of the larger story.

That chaos, apart from occasional preachiness, is actually the biggest weakness of “The State Within.” Even over six hours, the plot often gets irretrievably convoluted, to the point where trying to keep up becomes fruitless. Luckily, the plot details aren’t as important as how the characters react to them.

If “State” has another weakness, it’s the one-dimensional way in which some of its American characters are portrayed. They’re not stupid by any means but few of them are allowed the emotional complexity of the Brits. Sharon Gless’ Defense Secretary Warner in particular seems primarily defined by the combat death of her son.

Despite those problems, “The State Within” works most of the time, maybe not as a BBC take on “24” but as a deeper study of how terrorism still affects our lives and as a portrait of a man struggling to rediscover his idealism. In that it’s spot on.



Andrew Lyons is a Los Angeles writer and critic.




Latest headlines
Less Sparks: 'Idol' finale off 19 percent
Buyers pick ABC to lead in the upfront
Fact is, we've learned to accept spam
Tribute to Jay Leno, in his own words
Rachel, the guy is buds with my boss
Best tube bets this weekend

May sweeps: Fox leads ABC by 0.1 in adults 18-49
Bancroft family on Rupe: We're still not interested
Poll: Iowans trust traditional media for caucus news
Wheeling and dealing: XM courts used car owners
Maury in Montana: TV yakker launches newspaper

IAB: Online ad revenue hits record $16.9B in 2006
Internet radio stations reject royalties compromise
Bud wiser: A-B says failed TV site will fade away
Study: Web's the place to build buzz on entertainment