As timeshifting soars, a push to revisit C3
The networks argue that ads should be sold on C7 ratings
November 15, 2012
A decade ago, the only thing that mattered to media buyers and ad sellers was who watched TV the previous night.
Ratings were based on live viewing, and overnight ratings were the ultimate word in who had watched a particular show.
Then DVRs came along. Suddenly shows were being timeshifted from their traditional timeslots to whenever suited the viewer, and viewers could fast-forward through their ads.
Nielsen responded by making two big changes. First it began measuring DVR playback across a number of streams, including same-day, three-day and seven-day playback.
Second, it developed ratings for the commercial minutes themselves, separate from the programs, to determine how many people were staying tuned for the ads.
After a long, drawn-out debate, media buyers and the networks reached an agreement five years ago to change the currency ad buys are based on to C3 ratings, or commercial ratings including three-day DVR playback.
Fast forward to the present and another shift may be on the horizon. Now the networks are pushing buyers to switch the ad buying currency from C3 to C7 ratings
It’s a move that’s being met by skepticism among buyers.
“The networks, of course, are interested to increase C3 to C7 because it will get them more GRPs/impressions and allow them to keep their unit costs stable,” says Gary Carr, senior vice president and executive director of national broadcast at Target Cast tcm.
“Of course there would be advertisers like retailers and movies that would not be happy about this.”
The networks are pressing their argument hard. They point out that 46 percent of Nielsen households now have DVRs, more than double the amount five years ago.
They also note that people are time-shifting more frequently. A couple years ago no show was drawing 3 million viewers in live-plus-seven-day-DVR playback. Now 14 shows do so weekly.
CBS chief executive officer Les Moonves and Disney CEO Bob Iger both made a case for using C7 ratings for ad buys during recent earnings calls with analysts, echoing the pitch made by Ted Herbert, chairman of NBC Broadcasting, earlier this year.
But media buyers aren’t ready to commit to the change. Though they admit there could be some advantages, such as increasing inventory and thus stabilizing CPM increases, they still have reservations.
Many ads are time-sensitive, such as those promoting sales, and having viewers watch them several days later does not do the advertiser any good. Buyers don’t want to pay for such ads.
They are also interested in tracking not just delayed viewing but viewing across all sorts of screens, including web and mobile video.
Buyers note that Nielsen’s efforts to expand online ratings, which will include web video viewing, and finding a reliable way to track on-demand video would present a much clearer picture of who’s watching what and add new dimensions to the C7 ratings question.
“As technology improves audience metrics, changes will be in the offing. When, I can’t say,” Carr says.
“There’s the third screen audiences, and the desire for commercial audiences for that will also enter the picture.”
It’s probably inevitable that C7 ratings will be adopted as currency at some point, what with the rate of DVR adoption and delayed viewing.
But buyers will push to hold off as long as possible, and when they do acquiesce, they’ll want some concessions from the networks. What those concessions will be remains to be seen.
“There will be more discussions down the road,” predicts Carr.
First quarter’s winners and losers
This week’s daypart ratings
ABC’s ‘Scandal’ surges to record finale
Fox wins a Wednesday littered with reruns
Philly: Auto driving big TV dollars
Defining the big issues in digital video
A stunt that goes over the rainbow
‘Salem,’ this witches’ brew boils over
Tell us, what’s your forecast for the upfront?
Best tube bets this weekend
Tuesday cable overnights: Solid start for ‘Fargo’
NBCU: We’re ramping up digital content
‘Divorce Court’ up 24 percent this season
- Tim Pries, John Hunt and Judy Leung join Bonfire Labs
- Marco Frazier rises to SVP at AMC/Sundance Channel
- Kyle Ryan becomes online editor at Entertainment Weekly
- Nina Willdorf rises to editor at All You magazine
- Ajai Sehgal becomes chief technology officer at HootSuite
- Ricky Martin starring in Crackle special 'SuperSong'
- Coby Ryan McLaughlin joins the cast of USA's 'Graceland'
- Michelle Obama and Kellie Pickler guesting on ABC's 'Nashville'
- Former CBS and ABC news executive David Burke dies at 78
This week’s daypart ratings
This week’s cable ratings
This week’s broadcast ratings
This week’s top movies, songs and books
This week’s younger viewer ratings
This month’s new media traffic data
Media planner/buyer opening in Des Moines
Media planner/buyer opening in Austin
Online media buyer position in Provo, Utah
Digital media planner/buyer job in Minneapolis
Senior media planner job in Dallas/Fort Worth