As digital advertising grows, so do questions
It will surpass TV next year to become the No. 1 medium
March 11, 2016
There is little question that digital advertising is the future of media.
Just this week another forecaster, eMarketer, predicted that digital ad spending will pass TV to become the No. 1 medium next year, joining similar forecasts from Magna Global and ZenithOptimedia.
It’s a natural evolution.
People spend more time on digital now than most traditional media, and online ads are cheap, much cheaper than TV.
But as advertisers clamor for video, social media, mobile and other forms of digital ads, there’s a big question looming.
Does online advertising actually work? Or better, does it work so well that it deserves to siphon off great chunks of ad dollars from traditional media in all its forms?
One has to wonder.
Digital, for all its advantages, has a number of problems. Right up there is click fraud. How effective can an ad campaign really be if a quarter or a third or more of the ads the client is paying for are never seen by the target consumer?
Another problem is ad blocking, which raises the same question as above.
The big appeal of digital among advertisers has always been the ability to track results. But what good is that if the numbers are entirely skewed–made worthless–by click fraud and ad blocking?
But another huge issue–one that doesn’t get nearly the attention it deserves–is the dreadful quality of most online ad creative.
It’s all about driving clicks. It’s not about branding. In reality there is very little good branding online.
And the fact is, real advertising–advertising at its best and most effective–is and always has been about brand building.
Indeed, the rush online also seems to have erased advertisers’ memories. They’re abandoning media that for decades delivered results, notably magazines and newspapers.
The issue is not whether digital will continue to grow, or at what pace, but whether and when it will begin living up to advertisers’ inflated expectations.
In the meantime, the challenge for media buyers will be to make the best arguments for a balance of media that takes advantage of the best of each. That’s always been their role. Going forward, it will become a more critical one.
The eMarketer report makes a compelling case for the rise of digital. Spending will rise to $77.37 billion next year, totaling 38.4 percent of all ad dollars.
That’s well ahead of TV, which will be second at $72.01 billion, or 35.8 percent of all spending.
TV’s share is down from 39.1 percent in 2014, despite the fact that its ad dollars will be up by $4 billion. That’s because digital is growing even faster.
Digital dollars are up from $49.69 billion in 2014, a jump of 55 percent in just three years.
Mobile will, for the third straight year, account for the bulk of digital dollars in 2017, with $52.7 billion. That’s more than newspapers, magazines, radio and out of home combined.
A number of other forecasters have made similar predictions for TV and digital over the past year. Most see 2017 as the year digital pulls ahead. Internet ads jumped ahead of broadcast already, and broadcast accounts for the bulk of TV spending.
It’s easy to see what appeals to advertisers about digital. It’s much cheaper than TV, with a CPM of anywhere from $7 to $33 versus $1.90 to $10 for the web, according to investment banking company Peter J. Solomon.
And time devoted to the medium has soared. From 2010 to 2014, time people spend with digital media almost doubled, while traditional media time fell by more than 25 minutes, according to ZenithOptimedia.
‘Big Bro’ leads CBS to easy Wednesday win
One very sweet spectrum auction: $86 billion
Salt Lake City: Revving up for the Olympics
Traveler’s lament: ‘I wish I had a Samsonite’
What you need to know about black radio
Tell us, what’s your take on ad agency kickbacks?
Weekend TV: Oodles of Olympic qualifying
Yes, hate watching is a thing and it’s important
BET Awards take a tumble on Twitter
Hispanic TV: ‘El Señor de los Cielos’ flies high
NBC wins Tuesday with ‘Talent’ and trials
This week’s broadcast ratings
Programming blog: What’s canceled and renewed
- Karen Mawhinney, Kat Shafer and Jeff Hoffman rise at Erwin Penland
- Michael Angelovich and Danika Kirvin rise at Zimmerman Advertising
- Chris Watling becomes head of production at Droga5 London
- Nina L. Diaz rises to head of reality programming at VH1
- Paul Ricci becomes head of alternative at VH1
- Rory Levine and Tessa Jordan join CMT
- Mark Cuban hosting AXS TV summer concert series
- Mario Lopez launching Awestruck channel on YouTube
- 'The Daily Show' correspondent Jessica Williams exiting
This week’s broadcast ratings
This week’s cable ratings
This week’s top-rated movies, songs and books
This week’s daypart ratings
This month’s digital traffic data: May 2016
This month’s new media traffic data
Associate media director position in LA
Media assistant opening in Northern Virginia
Freelance broadcast planner/buyer available
Assistant media buyer job in Fort Worth
Needed in Louisville: In-house media buyer