Television
   
Homepage



Syndicated TV's
new star: 'Family Guy'


The off-network cartoon shoots to No. 1 comedy

Oct 4, 2007

Syndicators aren’t big experimenters, and for the best of reasons. What works best is what's worked before, as the ratings for the new season's syndicated shows makes clear.

That's off-network sitcoms.

In its first weeks in syndication, the animated “Family Guy" has shot up to become the No. 1 sitcom, ahead of long-running hits "Everybody Loves Raymond,” “Seinfeld” and “Friends,” and the first giant-sized hit since “Raymond” went into syndication several years ago.

"Family Guy” pulled a 4.2 household rating two weeks ago, the most recent available, up about 20 percent from its first week, according to Nielsen Media Research.

In contrast, new syndicated shows that had gotten a lot of buzz are pulling low to negligible ratings, like “Law & Order: Criminal Intent,” which is the first daily syndicated drama in years, the teen-skewing “Degrassi: The Next Generation,” which airs weekdays, and “Judge David Young,” syndication’s first openly gay judge.

That "Family Guy“ would do well is hardly surprising. It's how well that's the surprise.

"There’s a lot of loyalty to this program and it’s a fresh program in this environment,” says Amy McMahon, associate media director and lead syndication negotiator at Starcom.

That loyalty is such, she notes, that when Fox canceled it a few years back, fans snapped up so many DVDs of the show that the network brought it back.

But also driving the "Family Guy" numbers is the shortage of hit sitcoms on broadcast, along with waning ratings for most of syndication’s older comedies.

“It’s a pipeline issue,” says McMahon. “When networks stop being able to generate hits like ‘Friends,’ it affects syndication.”

That explains why “Two and Half Men” is also doing well in its first year in syndication, generating a 3.3 rating, ranking it above “Friends.”

Unfortunately the pipeline effect is not extending to ABC’s “George Lopez” and the CW’s “Half and Half,” also new to syndication. Nielsen hasn’t yet released national ratings for “George,” but the show pulled a 1.1 rating in metered markets, according to an analysis by Katz Television Group.

There is one new syndicated show that's entirely new that is working out, "TMZ," the edgy entertainment newsmagazine spun off the web site of the same name. The question was whether the show would be able to maintain the edginess of the site, and it's done just that, breaking the story of O.J. Simpson’s recent arrest.

Nielsen hasn’t released national ratings yet but in metered markets "TMZ" pulled a 2 household rating. While far below shows like “Entertainment Tonight,” it’s improving on its lead-ins and its timeslots from last season.

“Any station that has it has to be reasonably pleased with the initial numbers,” says Bill Carroll, vice president and director of programming at Katz. “You’re talking about better than a 1 rating, and in prime access it’s doing almost a 2, and you have [markets] where it’s doing 3s and 4s.”

Among dramas, the weekly “Cold Case” is doing well, pulling a 1.9 rating.

Of new talk shows, “Steve Wilkos,” a spinoff of “Jerry Springer,” is doing fairly well with about a 0.9 rating. That puts it in line with the returning “Martha.”

Less promising is the talk show “Morning Show,” which premiered earlier this year in a few markets. It’s pulling a 0.8 rating.

And game shows “Temptation,” which includes a home-shopping angle, and “Crosswords” are off to slow starts, with a 1.1 in metered markets and a 0.8 national rating, respectively.

“‘Temptation’ is being double run, usually in daytime and usually in less-visible time periods,” says Carroll. “‘Crosswords’ is in very difficult time periods, particularly in top markets where it’s taking on ‘Oprah’ and ‘Judge Judy.’”



Kevin Downey is a staff writer for Media Life.




Latest headlines
Your client cutting up on the ice
Weak return for ABC's 'FlashForward'
Leno wins week two by smaller margin
Words and ideas: New York Magazine
'Life,' visually stunning as life itself
Message right under your feet: Go NFL!
It's official: Amanpour joins ABC News
Rachel, what do I do about this woman?

Jerry Buhlmann rises to CEO at Aegis Group
Sandy Kolkey becomes president at Draftfcb New York
Lane Soelberg and Christine Bensen join Moxie Interactive
Icaro Doria becomes group creative director at Goodby

Paula Abdul's new gig falls through
Jeff Zeleny, Matt Bai and Jim Rutenberg shift roles at NYT
Tony Sherman becomes director of product operations at LogicLab
Beau Bridges joins NBC's 'The Rockford Files'



© 2010 Media Life Privacy Statement