Research
   
Homepage



Buyers see tougher
go for older media


Survey: They see a continuing erosion for print

Sep 4, 2007

Here are three words that have already dramatically reshaped American media and promise to do a lot more reshaping:

"Digital, digital, digital."

And for media buyers those three words sum up the state of media and its prospects looking ahead to fall 2007, according to a Media Life reader survey that was posted over the long holiday weekend.

Buyers believe traditional media will continue to suffer against the internet and other forms of digital media, and they are particularly pessimistic about newspapers and magazines as they attempt to confront the erosion of readers and advertisers brought on by the web.

More than three fourths of readers see an acceleration in the decline of newspaper circulation.

The question: Do you think the current slide in newspaper circulation will slow down by the end of the year or accelerate?

Nearly half, 45 percent, agreed with this statement: "It's bound to accelerate, especially now that some papers are trimming back on marginal circulation in outlying regions."

Another 31 percent agreed with this statement: "Actually, the slide will moderate for the coming year or so but then really speed up as more readers go online for their local news."

Just 22 percent believe the slides will continue but at a slower pace than in some recent reporting periods, in which declines averaged just over 2 percent. And a mere 2.3 percent think the slides will stop.

In magazines, which have seen a string of closures, buyers were asked to identify those most at risk. Nearly a third, 29.4 percent, picked the teen category as most likely to see another title folding. 

Second, at 17.5 percent, came the celebrity category, which many believe to be overcrowded. Just behind was the women's category, at 15.1 percent, and business/personal finance at 10.3 percent.

Of the two titles believed to be at risk, Business 2.0 and Radar, Business 2.0 leads in the minds of media buyers, at 11.1 percent versus 7.1 percent for Radar.

Most media buyers think magazines have done a poor job of coming up with creative ways to insulate themselves from the ravages of the internet, and by a large margin.

The question: Generally speaking, how good a job have magazines done in insulating themselves from further losses of readers and advertising to the internet?

Just 11 percent agreed with the statement: "Many have done a lot to integrate their online and print editions, which is key."

But 49 percent agreed with this statement: "Not nearly the job one might have expected, considering their vulnerability. They're still chasing ad pages to the exclusion of everything else."

Another 32 percent agreed with this statement: "Not much and for good reason. There's just not that much they can do to fend off the inevitable. Ad dollars are going to move online regardless."

And 8 percent agreed with this statement: "A terrible job. The industry is in deep trouble, and we are going to see a lot of titles suddenly closing."

But buyers' concerns go well beyond print. They're also pessimistic about broadcast TV this coming season, largely because of the flush of unscripted shows, whose numbers are equal to scripted dramas in primetime.

Readers were asked how the emphasis on reality will affect ratings.

Just 9 percent felt ratings would rise. And another 27 percent felt they would remain about the same, or dip slightly, agreeing with the statement: "People who watch network TV will watch whatever's put in front of them, and reality works as well as comedy, if not better."

The remaining 64 percent thought ratings would suffer, agreeing with the statement: "This is not about putting on shows that pull in viewers but about saving production dollars. The networks, particularly NBC, are shooting themselves in the foot to save a few dollars, and it will cost them dearly in the ratings this fall."

Buyers believe by a wide margin that broadcast will continue to lose viewers to cable, with 71 percent agreeing with the statement: "Yes. With one of baseball's league championship series moving to TBS and the continued success of ESPN's 'Monday Night Football,' cable could have a record fall."

Just 29 percent think broadcast will halt the slide, agreeing with the statement: "I think there are a number of compelling broadcast shows that will keep viewers engaged, while cable networks save their best shows for summer."

Further, most believe the networks will see the top shows continue their decline from last spring, with 69 percent agreeing with the statement: "This is a notable trend that I see continuing for some time. While it's not time to panic, it's certainly something to keep an eye on."

Fewer than a third, 31 percent, think last spring's slide will not continue, believing ratings will bounce back with the new season.

Buyers believe ABC has the best fall schedule, at 52 percent, followed by CBS at 18 percent and Fox at 17 percent. They believe MyNetworkTV has the worst lineup, at 32 percent, with NBC just behind at 26 percent.

Among other findings: Two thirds believe Don Imus will return to radio by Christmas and 46 percent believe Rupert Murdoch bought Dow Jones to bolster his soon-to-launch cable business news channel, rather than being motivated by ego (26 percent) or an intense desire to challenge The New York Times (28 percent.)

As for pegging the emerging trends that media buyers and planners should stay abreast of this fall, one reader summed it all up with this observation: “The internet is making everyone face changes in print and broadcasting.” 
 
“Buyers should be aware of the increase in online advertising, video on demand and interactive television spots,” wrote another.

Here are some of the other predictions:

--“Viewers watching the new season episodes online will be a big trend.” 

--“More and more television shows are going online, it's only a matter of time before one of the big four puts a series exclusively online. Maybe NBC will test it out with its younger 'My Name Is Earl' or 'The Office' viewers, but buyers must beware of this happening and it will happen soon.”
 
--“The big trend will be the increase in TiVo households and ability to skip ads becoming more widespread and all that entails. Also the increasing preponderance of digital options of all shapes, sizes and types.”



Lisa Snedeker is a staff writer for Media Life.




Latest headlines
CBS takes its first Thursday, a slow one
Preparing for life after 'Oprah' wraps up
'Happily Ever Faster,' don't bet on it
In Union Square, dunk Joey the Clown
Do you understand web measurement?
Agencies to Nielsen: Reinstate live stream
Rachel, help, we're being left in the dark
Best tube bets this weekend

BBC America president Garth Ancier steps down
Nicke Bergstrom becomes creative director at Mother New York
Nathan Hackstock becomes West Coast CD at Sapient Interactive
Frank Hahn and Naoki Ito become ECDs at W+K Tokyo

Catherine Balsam-Schwaber becomes SVP of marketing at iVillage
Chris De Luca becomes sports editor at the Chicago Sun-Times
Jennifer Howard rises to senior reporter at the Chronicle of Higher Education
James Van Der Beek files for divorce after six years



© 2009 Media Life Privacy Statement