The growth is coming but forecasts are split
By Heidi Dawley Mar 6, 2007
Search advertising is the great driving engine of online advertising, now accounting for some 40 percent of total spending. Yet it's lagged at the local level. Local advertisers have been slower to adopt the internet, and that's been especially so for search.
That's now changing, but just how quickly has forecasters divided. In a new report, Jupiter Research is predicting comparatively moderate growth for local search over the next several years, to $2.1 billion in 2011 from $935 million in 2006.
But Borrell Associates, consultants in local media, believes local search is already picking up the pace, and will speed up even more, actually quadrupling over a similar period. It's forecasting growth to $4.1 billion in 2010 from $1 billion in 2006.
The difference is just how quickly small business are adopting search, with Borrell believing they're further along on the learning curve than Jupiter.
As it stands now, overall local internet spending is behind in growth, accounting for around 25 percent versus 75 percent for national advertisers, according to Borrell, whereas in traditional media the breakdown is closer to 50-50.
That local would lag national internet spending is not all that surprising. Generally, national advertisers are faster to adopt new media, spending ahead of their competitors where they can. Local advertisers don't commit until they're sure they'll see fairly quick and sure returns.
But all that said, local internet spending has been picking up, and search is beginning to see more and more of those dollars.
Jupiter’s forecast pegs local search advertising growth at about 17 percent a year over the forecast period, pushing the category from 22 percent of local online advertising in 2005 to 26 percent in 2011.
But search will continue to lag behind classifieds. Jupiter is forecasting that local classifieds will grow from $3.0 billion in 2006 to $4.9 billion in 2011, while display will grow from $400 million to $1.0 billion
Jupiter believes big national marketers will remain the largest spenders in local search. “Local marketers are not yet completely convinced about local search,” says Sapna Satagopan, associate analyst at Jupiter Research.
In part this is because local advertisers are used to yellow pages advertising, which requires little work on their part. “With local search, the perception of higher effort acts as a barrier,” says Satagopan. But also holding back local search, she says, is that search providers have been slow to sell local advertisers on the medium, though that's beginning to change.
Borrell paints a far more robust picture of local search. “Now smaller companies are getting up to speed. The most rapid growth for search is in the small, local advertising arena,” says Colby Atwood, president of Borrell.
Borrell divides local search marketing into companies that have a local presence but are not locally owned versus locally owned companies. In 2006, some 44 percent of local paid search advertising dollars came from companies with a local presence but not locally owned, while 56 percent came from locally owned companies.
In general, Borrell forecasts that local search will grow from 24 percent of local online advertising spending in 2007 to 44 percent of the local online advertising category in 2010.
Borrell breaks local online advertising into a banner and listings category, which will still be a nose ahead in 2010 with 49 percent, local paid search, which will be at 44 percent, and email, which is forecast to hit 7 percent.
Meanwhile, in online ratings for the week ended Feb. 25, the top five parent companies were Microsoft, Google, Yahoo, Time Warner and News Corp. Online for the fourth straight week. The top five brands were also the same for the second straight week, Google, Yahoo, MSN/Windows Live, AOL Media Network and Microsoft.
Experian Group Limited was the top advertiser with 8.18 million impressions generated, more than double No. 2 NexTag at 3.93 million. With 19.15 million ads served, Yahoo was again the top advertising site, nearly tripling No. 2 MySpace at 6.61 million.
Sessions per person per week were down one from last week to 16, with domains visited per person even at 39. Average PC time per person per week was down nearly 3 percent to 16 hours and 54 minutes.
Top 25 parent companies Through Feb. 25
#
Parent
Unique Audience (000)
Reach %
Time Spent per Person (hh:mm:ss)
1
Microsoft
84,426
62.1
0:42:07
2
Google
78,852
58.0
0:31:03
3
Yahoo!
75,151
55.3
1:03:16
4
Time Warner
69,604
51.2
1:37:27
5
News Corp. Online
39,614
29.2
0:46:37
6
eBay
36,505
26.9
0:48:17
7
InterActiveCorp
28,961
21.3
0:13:43
8
Landmark Communications
22,629
16.7
0:20:20
9
Amazon
22,240
16.4
0:12:00
10
Apple Computer
21,307
15.7
0:32:59
11
Walt Disney Internet Group
19,699
14.5
0:18:30
12
RealNetworks, Inc.
19,074
14.0
0:16:23
13
Wikimedia Foundation
18,631
13.7
0:10:04
14
New York Times Company
16,631
12.2
0:10:21
15
United Online
14,391
10.6
0:26:35
16
CNET Networks
13,223
9.7
0:06:29
17
Viacom Digital
12,937
9.5
0:27:21
18
E.W. Scripps Company
12,008
8.8
0:06:17
19
AT&T Inc.
11,853
8.7
0:13:45
20
Bank of America
11,599
8.5
0:21:01
21
Verizon Communications
10,946
8.1
0:18:36
22
General Electric
10,930
8.0
0:07:44
23
Comcast Corp.
10,693
7.9
0:26:38
24
Gannett
9,993
7.4
0:11:53
25
CBS Corporation
9,474
7.0
0:11:17
Source: Nielsen//NetRatings
Top 25 brands Through Feb. 25
Parent
Unique Audience (000)
Reach %
Time spent per person (hh:mm:ss)
1
Google
75,188
55.3
0:25:04
2
Yahoo!
74,804
55.0
1:03:20
3
MSN/Windows Live
63,151
46.5
0:41:35
4
AOL Media Network
58,043
42.7
1:49:23
5
Microsoft
56,173
41.3
0:16:31
6
Fox Interactive Media
35,099
25.8
0:49:16
7
eBay
31,636
23.3
0:49:56
8
Apple
21,307
15.7
0:32:59
9
Weather Channel
20,495
15.1
0:21:29
10
Real Network
18,997
14.0
0:16:26
11
YouTube
18,862
13.9
0:24:38
12
Wikipedia
18,568
13.7
0:10:00
13
Amazon
17,511
12.9
0:11:37
14
Ask Search Network
17,397
12.8
0:14:17
15
About.com
11,815
8.7
0:03:25
16
CNN
11,793
8.7
0:16:17
17
Bank of America
11,211
8.3
0:20:54
18
Blogger
9,994
7.4
0:09:47
19
Nickelodeon Kids and Family Network
8,823
6.5
0:36:43
20
Comcast
8,709
6.4
0:30:46
21
PayPal
8,678
6.4
0:12:23
22
Gorilla Nation Media
8,306
6.1
0:06:31
23
IMDb - Internet Movie Database
7,945
5.9
0:08:01
24
Chase
7,889
5.8
0:17:02
25
Target
7,334
5.4
0:06:29
Source: Nielsen//NetRatings
Top 25 advertisers (excludes house ads) Through Feb. 25
#
Company
Impressions (000)
1
Experian Group Limited
8,176,562
2
NexTag, Inc.
3,931,519
3
Low Rate Source
1,731,853
4
Vonage Holdings Corp
1,568,557
5
HSBC Holdings plc
1,450,945
6
Netflix, Inc.
1,327,340
7
Verizon Communications, Inc.
1,093,806
8
Monster Worldwide, Inc.
1,076,372
9
AT&T Corp.
1,004,089
10
The General
996,004
11
United Online, Inc.
854,791
12
True
787,744
13
InterActiveCorp
686,442
14
Deutsche Telekom AG
675,376
15
PepsiCo, Inc.
632,130
16
Flingweb.com
615,077
17
Ford Motor Company
611,526
18
Scottrade, Inc.
498,658
19
Privacy Matters
490,669
20
TaxACT
486,299
21
Wachovia Corporation
440,445
22
Bank of America Corporation
437,986
23
AmeriValue
435,080
24
E*TRADE FINANCIAL Corp.
418,114
25
QuinStreet
417,758
Source: Nielsen//NetRatings AdRelevance
Top 25 advertising sites (excludes house ads) Through Feb. 25