|
When the Academy of Television Arts & Sciences announces its
Emmy nominations Thursday, viewers can expect snubs for a number of
deserving actors, actresses and shows, if tradition serves.
It's a safe bet, for example, that “Gilmore
Girls” and “Scrubs” will be passed over again.
But it's no less a safe bet, tradition being what it is, that the
Academy will again honor shows and actors well beyond their prime and long
past deserving more than a polite good-bye.
Certainly, “Lost,” “Desperate Housewives” and “House” will
push some old codgers from the ballots. But sentiment and familiarity will
still rule Thursday’s nominations, instead of talent and innovation.
Here are Media Life’s picks for five shows and actors who don’t
deserve nominations but will likely get them. Following we'll offer up
five who do deserve recognition but appear sure to be passed over.
Five
that don’t:
The
Sheens (Martin & Charlie)
Martin Sheen wasn’t on “The West Wing” enough
last season to warrant a Best Actor in a Drama nomination. In fact, the
show’s creative resurgence came when the focus moved from the White
House to the campaign trail.
And while Charlie Sheen’s “Two and a Half Men” is fun,
all Sheen does is play a bad boy with an eye twitch, which is to say
himself. Co-star Jon Cryer deserves a Best Actor in a Comedy nod. If
Charlie gets it, it will be because his last name is Sheen.
CBS’s
“CSI”
At least five other dramas (“Lost,” “Law
& Order: SVU,” “House,” “Veronica Mars,” “Deadwood,”
even an uneven “24”) had better seasons than TV’s most-watched show.
NBC’s
“Will & Grace”
The show has become an unintentional parody. Even its
superlative cast seems bored. There are more worthy Best Comedy nominees
on UPN, the WB, HBO and even struggling NBC.
Patricia
Heaton, Deborah on CBS’s “Everybody Loves Raymond”
She's a very competent actress who's been betrayed by her
writers. Her put-upon wife thing has gotten old after almost a decade. All
four “Housewives” leads deserve Best Actress in a Comedy consideration
ahead of Heaton. She'll get it simply because her show ended, which is as
dumb a reason as one could imagine.
Five
that do:
WB’s
“Gilmore Girls”
The show has the best cast on TV, yes, even better than
“Housewives.” None has ever received an Emmy nomination. If the
Academy can’t recognize Lauren Graham, it could at least give the show a
Best Comedy nod.
John
C. McGinley, Dr. Cox on NBC’s “Scrubs”
He delivers the longest, funniest one-liners on TV. If
Zach Braff is the heart of this excellent show, McGinley is the brains.
Gregory
Smith, Ephram on WB’s “Everwood”
He keeps a show that could be all sap and angst from
becoming a bad soap. Case in point: High school student Ephram learns that
he not only impregnated his ex-girlfriend but she's given the baby up for
adoption. Smith keeps the melodrama to a minimum and makes viewers truly
hurt for Ephram. That's called acting.
Kristen
Bell, Veronica on UPN’s “Veronica Mars”
Since the Academy lives in a five-channel universe--the
Big Four and HBO--voters undoubtedly have not seen UPN’s cult gem. They
should. Bell plays the most realistic high school student since Claire
Danes in “My So-Called Life.”
Peter
Gallagher, Sandy on Fox’s “The O.C.”
The show had a bad season but Gallagher provided, as
always, its moral center. He conveys more with one eyebrow than the entire
cast of “North Shore” could emote in a season.
|